69 Comments
User's avatar
Dr. Molly Rutherford's avatar

No thanks! Let's shrink government instead. Abolish the income tax too.

Bill Gaffney's avatar

Would be better off to amend the 17th Amendment and get rid of mob rule in electing senators.

Liz LaSorte's avatar

Yes! Where is that big, beautiful DOGE report that was due on July 4, 2026?

Skenny's avatar

It's not clear how we can afford to simply give money to honest Americans. We still have a lot of fraud to fund.

Laura Cornwell's avatar

It’s funny how $5000 per American would be so very inflationary, but foreign aid to African dictatorships and funding trans programs in Haiti to the same dollar value isn’t.

Note to self: It was my money in the first place, he’s just giving it back.

CStone's avatar

This. ALL. DAY. LONG.

David Nelson's avatar

Laura, "your" money was already spent before they got it. He's proposing to give us "newly printed" money, raising the debt.

Laura Cornwell's avatar

My point is, if our government feels we’re so flush with funds we can keep shelling it out to foreign countries, why is a little aid to American citizens such a problem? I happen to agree with you that our debt is a real problem and should be addressed first, but the reason our debt is so high is the government is so profligate with OUR money. I’d rather have my money back in my pocket than see it wastefully thrown at government spending I have no say on and get no benefit from. I’ve been paying in for well over fifty years, a few bucks back in my pocket is little enough.

Jpeach's avatar

How about a $5,000 federal tax credit per U.S. Citizen. $1.2 Trillion of recovered Government Fraud or Tariff Revenue must be documented, to pay for it.

Meddling Kid's avatar

How about a $10,000 tax DEDUCTION for US citizens instead, such that it would only be collected by those still paying over 10k in federal income tax, rather than a credit collected by those who pay no tax at all and are a net drain on public funds.

Jpeach's avatar

The Trump Administration could set up a PR Campaign that tracks and counts recovered Government Fraud and collected Tariff Revenue. We would root for the Trump Team to bring in the $1.2 Trillion, to win our $5,000 tax credit. If FanDuel can do it, the Treasury can do it.

FREED0ML0VER's avatar

A trillion here. A trillion there. Pretty soon we're talking about real money.

Bill Gaffney's avatar

Fiat money. Nothing but trust backs it up.

cds's avatar

The truth is… it’s OUR money that they steal from US! Then they play politics… with OUR money they stole from US!

David Nelson's avatar

cds, yes, they do that, but this is worse because that TRILLIONS of debt--that WILL BE PAID, in one form or another--will be paid by our, and our future descendants' production! THEY are spending/encumbering FUTURE production: when that value finally arrives in the future, we, and our future descendants, will find it ALREADY SPOKEN FOR. "Sorry! You worked 80 hours, yes, but your paycheck went to the nation's creditors."

Trump promised the ballooning debt was no problem because "Trump prosperity" would result in it--quickly--being paid off. Instead... what do we call it? <punt> I think he thinks "Ay-Eye" will be the Magic-Bullet Shell Game that shifts the debt onto some other poor b*st*rds.

Still. Still...

... I calm myself by asking "Where would we be if Kamalaladingdong were running things?" I think "favored constituencies" certainly would've already racked up more than $5k in bennies by now.

Ironically, do we now HAVE to elect Democrats to slow down Trump's march to socialism? NEITHER side understands "restraint."

SteveO's avatar

Well my friend. We have heard this all before so many times. But, My President is an extremely accomplished troller. He does these things to so that we can see and keep those politicians, mainly democrat socialists, to show their true stripes. They would love to give money to people, except if President Trump initiates it. He is always playing them so they show who they are. You and I and any sane person knows this. But I am for the Obama Care refund. They raped me and did not even kiss me. I was fined because my estimated income was higher than I thought and they took $5300 in kickbacks from me.

Heather B's avatar

I wonder if everyone who has TDS is going to forgo the check? I guess we'll see how much their TDS is worth to them. Also, none of them had any problem with Mamdani promising every free thing he could think of to buy votes so they can stuff it. I doubt it will happen anyway, since Congress has to approve it.

Vee's avatar

Wasn't there talk about getting rid of income tax? How about we do that instead of talking all of this nonsense.

DJL's avatar

I can be bribed😎

Meddling Kid's avatar

Often just with food. Mmmmmm…brisket. OOOooooo…pizza too!?!?! Hey guys, they got ice cream!!!

John Wright's avatar

Every dollar the government spends (gives away) is one more dollar contributing to inflation. We are watching the value of our money vaporize. Buy Gold.

As for Trump's promises... unfortunately he talks too much.

As for the digital wallets... have you tried to buy a senior lifetime national park pass? Sign yourself up for digital prison (and the government will let you visit our nice parks).

Bill Gaffney's avatar

Have a card I bought years ago at Yellowstone. Still have the plastic card.

John Wright's avatar

I plan on visiting one of the parks and trying to buy one in person. Online forces you to go the digital prison route.

Gerry Ganong's avatar

Brilliant, as ever! Oh the [chronic] incongruity of the American tribal experience! You make me laugh AND think.

Sheila's avatar

Why isn't he promising lower gas prices? And the end of the Iran war? Things we actually care about??

Hmm maybe because it's all just talk...

Connie Lemmincakes's avatar

Every time I see what gas costs I think it’s gonna cause issues in November.

Phxrising8's avatar

Last night he said gas prices will fall AFTER the midterms. 🙄

KC's avatar

"(Although Trump would undoubtedly argue that nobody’s stimulus package is as big as his.)" LOL.. Jenna talking dirty for 8 bucks a month and Pierre Kory trying to sell me water stuff... ah Capitalism... :)

BKamm's avatar

So this money is supposed to go to “every adult CITIZEN.” Could be a fabulous plan to detect (and then deport) illegal non-citizens!

David Baldwin's avatar

This is outright bribery! And a desperate attempt to keep Republicans in power. I'm on the fence with this. On one hand, the extra money will definitely be spent (hopefully) mostly on goods and services in the US increasing the economy. On the other hand, it will raise the national debt. Which would you rather have: more money chasing goods and services or more national debt?

My brain just exploded when thinking about the tax implications. Tax on the $5,000 about 20%. Tax (state tax if applicable) on what you buy with it is anywhere from 1% to 6%. So you're not really getting $5,000. You're getting roughly anywhere from $3,760 to $4,000. Don't even think about the erosion by inflation on that money. Your brain will definitely go bonkers!

CStone's avatar

Outright bribery?

Mandamnthee promised free rent, free food. Ovomit promised “the oceans would roll back” because Al-puke-lah

David Nelson's avatar

"Which would you rather have: more money chasing goods and services or more national debt?"

We don't have to choose! When government just prints and spends money that they don't have, we get both! It's a lose-lose!